Crowd-pleasing Super bowl Cookies recipes for your football watch party
You’ll love these Super bowl cookies recipes that’ll keep your football watching crew happy. There are big cookies, easy no-bake bars, and bar cookies that everyone will love. I’m talking about big honking cookies that’ll put those sad store-bought cookies to shame.
Nobody wants to go to a football potluck without some kind of good dessert, and these ones deliver big with bold flavors and looks without a ton of work. Let’s be real; when you’re making food for a crowd, you don’t want to fuss too much over dessert.
Also, all of these recipes travel well, so if you’re packing things up to go to a friend’s house to watch the big game, you can be rest assured that you won’t lose anything in transit. All of these can be carried in my favorite 1 gallon Rubbermaid TakeAlongs for easy anxiety-free car rides!
On that note, here are my favorite choices for crowd-pleasing cookies that will feed a big crowd.
Superbowl Cookies Recipes
Reese’s Pieces Peanut Butter Cookies
Easy peanut butter cookies with a little bit of oatmeal and a whole lot of Reese’s Pieces for double peanut butter flavor. With all the colors of football itself, these cookies will call to you from the dessert spread at your tailgate!
Ultimate High Altitude Chocolate Chip Cookies: no more flat cookies
Too often chocolate chip cookies baked at altitude are decidedly not Mile-High, leaving you with sad, flat overly crisp, too brown cookies. Science and a whole lot of testing went into these amazing high altitude chocolate chip cookies. They bake up soft with a crisp edge and no collapsing! Let these be the star of your next football party.
Big soft sugar cookies to make people happy
You’ll wonder why you ever bought Lofthouse cookies after one bite of these tender, ultra soft perfect sugar cookies They’re big, soft, and perfect in their simplicity. These make a big batch, so they’re excellent when you get called on to bring snacks for your kids’ baseball or softball teams. Don’t let the looks fool you; these cookies will be a hit every single time.
Peanut Butter Brownie Cookies will satisfy your Reese’s craving
The perfect fudgy brownie cookie filled with peanut butter and loaded with Reese’s peanut butter cups. If you love peanut butter cups, these are calling your name. When you can’t decide between a peanut butter cookie and a chocolate one, this is the perfect choice.
Chocolate Cookie dough bark is crazy easy to make
Make cookie bark when you want to bake but you’re too tired to think. The crisp Oreo tasting edges covered with white chocolate will be balm for your mind if your team is down at halftime.
The best loaded crispy oatmeal cookies
This is the perfect oatmeal cookie with your favorite mix-ins. While white chocolate and cranberries is a house favorite, you can get creative with what you add to these cookies. For Game Day, stir in some M&Ms in your team’s colors.
Giant chocolate sugar cookies that’ll make your team cheer
Big puffy sugar cookies get a healthy dose of chocolate for the ultimate bakery style giant chocolate cookie. Make them plain or add your favorite chocolate candy, perfect for using up holiday candy.
Chocolate Rice Krispie treats are the last minute potluck’s savior
Make these no-bake bars when you have a last minute potluck to go to and you want something chocolatey but no patience to bake more. These bars are a great place to mix in extras like coconut or chocolate trail mix.
Confetti Sugar Cookies: sprinkles make cookies better
The perfect soft sugar cookies get the sprinkles treatment for big soft confetti cookies. These cookies are the perfect party cookie. For the Superbowl, roll the dough in colors for both teams and have people choose cookies based on their predictions for some extra dessert fun.
Lemon Crinkle Cookies are a bake sale favorite with surprising softness
Super soft sugar cookies are made even softer with the addition of lemon juice. These cookies will stay soft for days and have a pleasing bright citrus flavor that’s welcome any time of year.
Cookies and Cream Cookies just brought Oreos out to party
Big soft sugar cookies with brown sugar and crushed Oreos topped with glossy marshmallow cream frosting. I’ve never been to a Superbowl party without Oreos, so why not elevate them by stirring them into a batch of these amazing soft cookies?!
Twix cookies are amazing and totally over the top
Loaded with Twix soft chocolate sugar cookies topped with glossy caramel and swizzles of chocolate stripes and of course, more Twix for a decadent bakery style cookie that’s a party all on its own.
The best Monster Cookies
Big mostly oatmeal peanut butter cookies loaded with ALL THE CHOCOLATE. Any caramel or chocolate candy works for these cookies, and boy howdy there’s a lot of it in these cookies. These are stand up and cheer cookies.
Peanut Butter Rice Krispie Treats are your favorite but better
Ack, you got called to a friend’s house for a last-minute football watch party, and they still need dessert. What do you do, dear? Make these awesome fluffernutter tasting trail mix loaded peanut butter rice krispie treats in 10 minutes flat and be the hero of the day.
No-fuss Superbowl cookies ideas
Everybody needs friendly cookie recipes that’ll please anyone. These Superbowl cookies ideas are perfect for potlucks or football watch parties you may be having with your neighbors and friends. Everything travels well too, because nobody wants to worry about smearing the tops of your dessert while you’re driving.
What are your favorite Super Bowl cookies? I know there are a ton of creative ideas out there like these little referee decorated Nutter Butters, but a good cookie will always be appreciated even if you don’t have the decorator’s touch.
